In a recent article, Dr. Christopher Kaczor, President of the American Catholic Philosophical Association, explores a secular argument against abortion.
Dr. Kaczor highlights American atheist philosopher Don Marquis’ reasoning that abortion is wrong because it deprives an unborn child of a “future-like-ours”, the experiences, relationships, and opportunities for a meaningful life that they could have. Marquis’ argument applies the same principle used to explain why killing adults or newborns is wrong and does not rely on religion or belief in a soul.
The article also addresses common objections, including whether this reasoning conflicts with contraception or the possibility of a difficult future, showing why Marquis’ argument remains consistent and compelling.