By Michael Cook
Although Dutch government proposals for euthanasia for “completed life” – that is, for elderly people who want to [end their lives preemptively] – have received a lot of publicity, they have not been legislated.
Now the Royal Dutch Medical Association (KNMG), the peak body for doctors in the Netherlands, has announced its opposition. “Such a radical proposal is not desirable for practical reasons and for reasons of principle,” says the KNMG [which otherwise supports euthanasia in the Netherlands].
Adding another law to govern the practice of euthanasia will lead to great complications, it contends. “The current Act is meticulous, transparent, verifiable, safe for patients and physicians, and has broad support.” [MCFL would dispute that killing patients is safe under any reasonable standard.]
The government’s proposal would harm the elderly. “Vulnerability due to age, when people experience many medical and non-medical problems, can cause unbearable and hopeless suffering within the meaning of the legislation.” It could end up stigmatizing the elderly.
The KNMG points out that the term “completed life” has an attractive ring to it for the public. “In practice, however, it will mainly be vulnerable people who experience loneliness and loss of meaning. These are complex and tragic problems for which [there are] no simple solutions.”
This article originally appeared on the website BioEdge.org. The opinions and assertions are those of the original author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Massachusetts Citizens for Life, its staff, or board. Editorial insertions for clarity and/or viewpoint adjustment are in brackets and italicized. The article is reprinted under a Creative Commons license.